Showing posts with label freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label freedom. Show all posts

Thursday, 6 September 2012

Are we living in the Matrix?


I know what you're thinking — you're thinking 1. that I'm crazy and 2. that this is old hat. When The Matrix came out in 1999 many people talked about whether we live in it or not. Let me reassure you that I am not interested in that. The other day as I drove to work I was idly considering Morpheus' statements about the Matrix and I realised that although I don't believe we are living in exactly what he described, there is one social institution that, almost word for word, can replace the word Matrix when Morpheus mentions it. Consider the following quote:
The Matrix is everywhere. It is all around us. Even now, in this very room. You can see it when you look out your window or when you turn on your television. You can feel it when you go to work... when you go to church... when you pay your taxes. It is the world that has been pulled over your eyes to blind you from the truth. That you are a slave, Neo. Like everyone else you were born into bondage. Born into a prison that you cannot smell or taste or touch. A prison for your mind.
What is everywhere? What is a lie? How are we enslaved? The answer, when it struck me, was obvious: the State. In fact I think Donald Livingston is correct when he says that the modern State, while presenting itself as republic or democracy (or a combination), has little more in common with those modes of government than it has with, say, monarchy. Instead we can call it the Leviathan State, the Total State, that form of government in which one will — that of the supreme People — alone is sovereign over any and all desires of individuals themselves. Of course this is pure fiction — there is no such thing as "the People", there are only individuals. In the Total State there are broadly two classes of individuals: those who produce and pay taxes and those who consume and receive taxes. The fiction is necessary to keep the tax-payers paying without too much complaint. Speaking of fiction:
What is the Matrix? Control. The Matrix is a computer-generated dream world built to keep us under control in order to change a human being into this. [Energy]
Needless to say the dream world we live in is not the product of a computer program, it is the product of a vast edifice of ideas and lies that tell the human mind it is more free as a slave, more wealthy as a vassal, more wise to be ignorant. The State exists to control the taxed and redirect the wealth they produce for the ends of those who control the State — mostly the "liberal" intellectual and the political class. More generally it is those that live from the proceeds of taxes. For most people of either class, since the State is all they've known people promote it and prefer it:
The Matrix is a system, Neo. That system is our enemy. But when you're inside, you look around, what do you see? Businessmen, teachers, lawyers, carpenters. The very minds of the people we are trying to save. But until we do, these people are still a part of that system and that makes them our enemy. You have to understand, most of these people are not ready to be unplugged. And many of them are so inured, so hopelessly dependent on the system, that they will fight to protect it. 
 A more fitting description of those who daily defend the violence of the State even as it engages in violence against them is hard to imagine. This type of person is the chief enemy of liberty, even though he would be the chief beneficiary of it. And why? Because he believes in the State. He cherishes its power to curb the vices of others. Every year he makes his offering of cash, if grudgingly, to ensure that the dangerous liberty of others is crushed by the State. In a sense this is the core belief of those who support the Total State. They believe freedom is dangerous, not because they themselves would abuse it, but because other people would. Others would produce bad and dangerous products, others would rampage with guns, others would spend their money with profligacy, others would fail to care for the parents and children. It is fear of the liberty of others. While this fear governs all thought any excuse will do to curb the freedom of others. Most of the time the excuse is not needed, it is simply treated as self-evident, and the individual may go on in ignorance:
I know this steak doesn't exist. I know that when I put it in my mouth, the Matrix is telling my brain that it is juicy and delicious. After 9 years, you know what I have learned? [Eats the piece of steak and sighs contently] Ignorance is bliss.
Not all people are content with ignorance, however. The State needs a permanent army of intellectuals ready to do battle in its name. They constantly fight the war of ideas to make the insane and irrational basis for the State look like science and wisdom. They must be the gatekeepers of information and the teachers of the next generation. They must be in all places, at one moment an ordinary person, the next an Agent ready to crush the ideas of liberty with a chimera of arguments. Because the State cannot tolerate the spread of anti-State ideas. Its power and permanence are founded on lies and ideas, so any outbreak of truth and the ideas of liberty, that the State is not only not necessary but antithetical to human flourishing must be crushed without delay.
That means that anyone we haven't unplugged is potentially an agent. Inside the Matrix, they are everyone and they are no one. We have survived by hiding from them, by running from them, but they are the gatekeepers. They are guarding all the doors, they are holding all the keys, which means that sooner or later, someone is going to have to fight them.
I won't lie to you, Neo. Every single man or woman who has stood their ground, everyone who has fought an agent has died. But where they have failed, you will succeed. I've seen an agent punch through a concrete wall. Men have emptied entire clips at them and hit nothing but air. Yet their strength and their speed are still based in a world that is built on rules. Because of that, they will never be as strong or as fast as you can be.
Now, I admit this might be stretching the analogy a bit, but hear me out and judge for yourself. The ordinary person may occasionally wake from the fiction of the State, but when he does he faces the intellectual equivalent of an Agent: a barrage of ideas all centred around the goal of convincing him that the State is the solution to his problems, and not their principal cause. That is why every day I seek to arm myself with the only weapon that can defeat the State: truth. Truth is the sword that never loses its edge, it is the shield that remains forever intact and perfect. It kills the Leviathan by unmasking its friends as the fiends they are and defeating its hubris, turning the ordinary person who formerly loved the State into its unwavering enemy. The State lives in the mind, so every person who rejects the State, is enabled to pierce the fog of lies that surrounds it and see its true nature, is a death of the State. Every time someone wakes up and sees the justice and reason of liberty, the State dies.
Let me tell you why you're here. You're here because you know something. What you know you can't explain, but you feel it. You've felt it your entire life, that there's something wrong with the world. You don't know what it is, but it's there, like a splinter in your mind, driving you mad.
Mises knew it. He saw that all was not right, that the State could not be God. He helped provide us with the ideas that build on the foundation of human liberty, that advance the cause of freedom and bring death to the State not with violence but with the gentle whisper of thought.

The following is a modified quote, also from The Matrix. See if you can work out the original: "Do not try to defeat the State — that's impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth: there is no State. Then you will see it is not the State that dies, only your support of it."
I know you're out there. I can feel you now. I know that you're afraid... you're afraid of us. You're afraid of change. I don't know the future. I didn't come here to tell you how this is going to end. I came here to tell you how it's going to begin. I'm going to hang up this phone, and then I'm going to show these people what you don't want them to see. I'm going to show them a world without you. A world without rules and controls, without borders or boundaries. A world where anything is possible. Where we go from there is a choice I leave to you.
Why does the State fight so stolidly against liberty? Why must it crush the ideas of freedom and spread its influence into every aspect of life? I put it to you that it is because the State is fragile. Leviathan is not a battleship but a jellyfish. Its justification is so tenuous, so patently illogical and unreasonable that it fears even a hint of truth. It cannot stand to be examined, to be argued and debated. It cannot abide opposition even from a child. That is why if we stand ready to engage the soldiers of the State, if we argue and oppose it, if every day we walk the path of truth it is as a body blow to the State. We may never wake to find that there is only seawater where before the jellyfish swum, but we can enjoy the warm glow that comes from sticking Leviathan in a tender spot. The truth can be its own reward, and that may entice us to strive against the State, not giving in to it but proceeding ever more boldly against it. I don't know the future. I do know that the Mises Institute and its academics and contributors are showing us a world without the State. A sea with no jellyfish. I, for one, intend to take a swim.

Thursday, 1 March 2012

STOP PRESS Scientist announces results of experiment without using a control group

A recent article in The Conversation has me wondering what Linda Weiss did to become a scientist. She argues that all economies benefit from the interaction of the State, and that some how the evidence for this is that all contries have experienced government interference in their economy:
State “guidance” of the economy, in the broadest sense, is the shared history of all countries that have successfully industrialised.
... It is not that one set of countries practise “free-market capitalism” while another set practise “state-guided capitalism”. It is closer to the truth to point to the differing ways in which all economies – whether emerging or advanced – draw on state involvement in guiding and shaping development. It is recognition of this point that is long overdue in mainstream economic and political thinking.
... it has been the rapid rise of China and other emerging giants, India and Brazil – the so-called BICs — that has done more to challenge the Washington Consensus idea that state activism is always inimical to economic prosperity.
So, all countries have experienced state guidance of industry, their industry has grown, and this means that state guidance is a good thing. That's like saying that all people die, people are a good thing, therefore death is a good thing. All cats have four legs; my dog has four legs, therefore my dog is a cat.

I hope that by now you are getting the picture: she has taken a sample of all cubes and says there's no such thing as a circle. You must have a control group in any experiment - in this case it would involve looking at economies that were not controlled by the state. Since no such economy has ever lasted long, at least not recently, we have no data on that front. However, the Adam Smith Institute has an article that examines the next best thing - plotting economic prosperity against state interference in the economy, and it tells a rather different story:
As you can see there is definitely a correlation there, and it doesn't come down in favour of state interference. I'm not going to call that a clinching argument - clearly there are other factors at play since for a freedom rating of 7, for example, there is a wide variance of GDP per capita, but it strongly supports the case that government interference is killing the economy, not helping it.

Wednesday, 28 September 2011

9/11 Conspiracy Theories

The Americans love a good conspiracy theory. It's been their major export for some decades now, so when the 9/11 attacks occurred the cynical could have placed safe bets on the emergence of a fresh series of conspiracy theories about the events of that terrible day. I'm not going to try to answer all the hair-brained stuff that's come to light from dark corners of the internet - that has been done much more comprehensively and expertly than I could do, but I do want to talk about some of the things the conspiracy theorists have right and wrong.

The origin of conspiracy
I think the conspiracy theories are very significantly influenced by the convenience that the attacks afforded the US government, particularly Dick Chainey. In all times of great tragedy there are those that abuse it for gains in power or status or money, or all of the above. Those that capitalise on the events for personal gain are perfect fodder for the conspiracy theorists' delusions - after all, the gains are great, so they had motive to cause these events. In the case of 9/11 the invasion of Iraq is particularly glaring. To this day I don't know the motivation for doing it. By comparison, invading Afghanistan was perfectly logical (Bin Laden was a Saudi) and a measured response (more than 8000 civilians dead and counting) to the 9/11 attacks. I can only assume that it was galling that in 1991 they couldn't actually invade and they wanted to make up for it, combined with a perceived need for the oil security. If so, it's just about the most expensive oil ever bought, since it has cost at least $3 trillion, which is short to write but it's a truly catastrophic amount of money, and if anything it's a gross underestimate since many fine young men have suffered severe and permanent physical and mental trauma, and of course a fair number have been killed in action.

Leaving aside the legitimacy and pointfullness of the war, though, it's a great "motive" for the 9/11 theorists to cite. Apparently the desire by some to go to war was so extreme that they would go to enormous lengths to make it happen, even orchestrating a terrorist attack. Here follows some conspiracy theories and my generalised rebuttal.

Controlled demolition
For me, this one pretty much takes the cake in terms of implausibility. The American government secretly wired a building in the middle of their greatest city with explosives? The explosives were not set off by the massive shock of a heavy jet hitting them and the resultant jet-fuel fireball? And they worked perfectly, just at the moment the towers were starting to fall?
and someone was watching, waiting for the perfect moment to set them off even though the buildings might easily have collapsed anyway? This gets a full 5/5 flying saucers. There are some outstanding facts that are hard to explain for the "conventional" school (i.e., the buildings came down because they were hit by heavy jets and exposed to extensive, raging fires) but 9/11 is a unique event, so there are bound to be some facts that are hard to understand. A mysterious fountain of sparks that looks suspiciously like thermite is one example. Unfortunately quite a few "experts" have gone on record as saying that it was controlled demolition. I'm all for academic freedom, but these guys are missing a trick: THE BUILDINGS WERE HIT BY HEAVY JETS. Stress concentration is one thing I see not mentioned by any structural or materials engineer who goes for the controlled demolition theory. When combined with fire, it's obvious to me why these buildings failed while no other steel structure has ever collapsed due to fire. A significant amount of the supporting structure had been wiped out asymmetrically. This would seem to cause a torque on the whole building around where the plane hit, and combined with the effect of heat lowering the yield stress of steel ... like I said, obvious.

Aircraft autopiloted into WTC

This is as daft possibly even dafter than the one above. The terrorists were in the cockpit. They had taken flying lessons. We have lots of documentary evidence for both of those facts. So why is it that someone would insist the planes were guided into the WTC by their autopilots which had been remote programmed? I'm not saying this is impossible, but on a scale of 1 to 5 UFOs it gets 4.5 for sheer brain shutdown.

United 93 was quickly removed/shot down by missile
This is one the conspiracy theorists have right. The wreckage from United 93 was removed very fast - at the moment of impact, in fact. By an enormous jet fuel fireball. The circumstances of its crash were unlike most aircraft crashes. Most aircraft crashes that happen on land are what you might call a severely botched landing. The pilots try to land or mitigate the crash so lose altitude slowly if possible and come in parallel to the ground. Tragically, the evident struggle in the cockpit of that plane caused the controls to be manipulated in such a way that the plane made a hard right bank - I'm guessing a rudder hard-over, which would be consistent with someone kicking indescriminately if they were struggling - and then went nose first into the ground. Such an impact is unusual in that there is a lot of force acting directly on the airframe, causing it to shatter into much smaller pieces than normal. The concomitant fireball would send these pieces right out of the park. The sheer number of witness accounts make this one a fairly watertight case so I give it 4.5 crop circles out of five.

In a sense all of these conspiracy theories are the same. It's always the government or "they" - forces within the government - that is doing it to its own people. And in a sense they have it right - all governments do terrible things to their own people, especially in this current age of unprecedented power over their people. But conspiracy theorists also miss the point. Airing conspiracies with house of cards levels of documentation is not going to convince people en masse - indeed, a lot of sites propound a whole swathe of conspiracy theories, some legitimate concerns, and others complete bunkum, and in doing this play into the hands of any forces that genuinley want to keep certain information out of public eye. The best place for a true conspiracy is among half a dosen fakes. That way no one with an ounce of common sense is going to believe any of it. In that way there is conspiracy hegemony: either you believe all the conspiracies (if you have taken leave of your senses) or you believe none. To give serious thought to any conspiracy automatically moves you in to the conspiracy camp and gives your word the same weight as someone who still believes in aliens, so few people would do it.

Conspiracy theorists' credibility problem derives from their ignorance of Ockham's razor and Hanlon's razor. Combine this with sources that themselves are not credible (some have reasonably scientific methods but also point to other conspiracy sites or known conspiracists) and cherry-picking of evidence, and you have total loss of credibility. The only difference between an investigative journalist and a conspiracist is that one is a lot more rigorous. In short, conspiracists suffer from insufficient skepticism and rigor. Until and unless they get their act together there's little chance that any genuinely concerning things they report will ever become known before it's too late to do anything about them.

The other major problem with all of these conspiracy theories is they fail to draw attention to the civil liberties that were considered basic human rights before the attacks but have since been eroded or destroyed. New powers were granted the government, just as new powers were granted Hitler during crises, and these powers were mostly used to repress ordinary citizens, although the rhetoric was about protecting the public from sleeper terrorists and the like.

I always cringed when Bush said something like, "They hate us for our freedoms." From day one I knew that couldn't possibly be true. No one attacks someone else just because they have more liberty. The reasons for the attack are complicated no doubt, but they tend to boil down to a reaction to American imperialism. Speaking of liberty in this way debases it by making it a pretext for treading on the liberties of foreigners in the middle east and the people at home. Governments around the world have proved that Bush's retoric has a place: we the free people can say of most governments that, "They hate us for our freedoms."