Saturday, 20 August 2011

The Fallacy of the Technological Singularity

The Technological Singularity, or usually just "The Singularity" is a concept unfamiliar to most, I think, except technologists and futurologists, people who study computer science and artificial intelligence, and a few random others - actually quite a few people, probably. Sigularity is a term that has various meanings in physics, geometry, calculus, common speech and of course futurology. In all of them, however, it means something along the lines of "a discontinuous point". Generally this tends to be a point at which the tools we can use to help us understand the rest of the continuum no longer work. The Technological Singularity is a predicted point somewhere in the near future at which technological progress will become so accelerated that it will look "discontinuous".

Many people are familiar with Moore's Law. I have mentioned it in a previous blog entry. I may have waxed boring but I'm blogging to improve my writing skills, so do give me a break. Essentially the law (more like a forecast, really) states that processing power doubles every 2 years. This forecast also helps the technology companies decide how much R&D they need to do if they want to keep up. In that way it is a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy, but the trend was already there to find before it was found, so one can guess that even if the trend had never been identified we'd still have roughly the computing power we do. Now, the futurist would say, let us assume that Moore's Law will hold for the coming decades. Soon we will have a computer so powerful that it will be able to emulate the human brain. And suppose that intelligent computer were used to design a computer more powerful and intelligent than itself. Then we build its design and use the result to design an even more powerful and intelligent computer. The rate of progress is now no longer exponential, since we used human intelligence to achieve exponential progress - if we have a computer four times better than the human mind then we can have a computer twice as powerful as it in six months, rather than two years. Then we use that computer we got six months later, which is eight times more powerful than the human brain, to develop another computer in three months that is sixteen times more powerful than the human brain. The result of this is the Singularity - an escalating spike of many-times exponential technological progress. Before four years had passed the mathematical trend I just mentioned would mean that computer power was practically infinite.

The chart below illustrates this:

Here we see the singularity forming based on the scenario above

If we take the base 2 logarithm of this period we get the following result:

Normal technological growth would show up as a straight line. The scenario of the Singularity results in a perverse acceleration of technological development.

Of course there are limiting factors. It will take time to construct every iteration. There is a limited supply of resources and energy. The computer intelligences may well increase these supplies by inventing new technologies but they do have ultimate limits which cannot be exceeded.

The scenario I have outlined above is fairly simplistic but it is essentially what people expect from the events leading up to the Singularity. There are many doomsday or utopian predictions for what the fate of the human race will be in all this. It is these concerns that I wish to address. Futurists believe that the Singularity is inevitable - not in the same way that you might believe a minor accident is inevitable if you drive around for long enough - in the genuine no-possible-way-of-avoiding-it imperative super inevitable. They do not believe that it is even conceivable that the Singularity will not occur. In the words of John J. Xenakis, "No. No way. It's impossible. The Singularity cannot be stopped. It's as inevitable as sunrise."* I believe I can prove that the Singularity cannot occur.

There seem to be two general schools of thought on how the singularity will come about. One school believes that there will be computer or "robot" intelligences, the other, which I shall call the Singularity Cult, believes that the first hyper-intelligences will be human intelligences augmented by machines. The Singularity Cult hopes that it will be them.

I do not belive that either of these scenarios will result in a singularity. This is because I question the assumptions that go into the scenarios and result in the Singularity. Namely, the assumptions are these:
1. Computers can become genuinely aware.
2. Machine-mind neural interface is possible.
3. Production of new intelligences will accelerate.

If assumption one is incorrect, the Singularity can never occur. Let us assume for the moment that intelligence is an emergent property of the type of architecture that the human brain uses. We can create computers with similar architecture - in fact IBM have recently done so (they say) - and they may be able to solve problems in an intelligent way. But everything that chip does will be directed by human intervention. It will not by itself decide to create anything apart from the networks and programs it needs to do what we ask it to do. It is not self-directing, and I do not see any evidence that we will ever be able to create a computer that is self-directing. It will always and only take those directives and inputs we give it.

If only assumption two is incorrect, we are all in le merde. The machines will not care about us and they will use up all the energy in the world, returning us to the stone age overnight. We would destroy the machines before they could take control of the power supply, so the Singularity would not occur.
This is another thing technologists are sure of. My view is that the human brain is so complex that a reliable interface cannot be produced, no matter how many millenia of research are poured into it. The brain constantly changes its structure and the locations of various functions. It is - in a word - organic, it adapts to circumstance and every brain is unique in the particular way it processes, stores and retrieves information. We so far understand only the most basic aspects of how the most "basic" functions such as vision and other senses and regulatory systems work, we not much closer to understanding true intelligence than when we first used a sharpened bit of wood to kill a deer.

If assumption three is incorrect the Singularity cannot occur, and technological process will go back to being regularly exponential, albeit at a much higher multiplier.
My beef with this particular assumption is on much more solid ground than the other two. There is a finite rate at which resources can flow - both power and those resources required to build the intelligences. It also takes time to develop and construct the tools necessary to build the intelligences. All of these things put a limiter on the speed with which new intelligences may be created. Let's say the shortest time required to make a new one is one month. In my earlier example, that would cause the rate of progress to return to being regularly exponential, because the time axis is linear but the computing power axis is exponential. No matter how steep this new computer power/time line is, it will not result in a singularity. Technological progress will be extremely rapid, but it won't "fall up a cliff" as in the Singularity.

The following chart illustrates what might happen in this case:

Technological progress continues on in a single exponential trend - on this log base 2 normalised graph it is a straight line.

Much computing research is now in the field of neural network architecture and adaptive evolutionary code. It seems clear that this will eventually result in machines that far exceed the limitations of today's computers. They may see and hear and speak. They will certainly produce new inventions and new science - in fact they already have - but ultimately, they will be built by humans, for humans, and work produced by them will belong to humans. We will never be mastered by intelligent machines, because such machines are not truly intelligent. They simulate intelligence because we design them to. They speak, hear and see because we want them to. They may even kill, if we design them to. They will never be able to decide not to follow an instruction that is built in. They are tools - very sophisticated tools - but nevertheless have no moral superiority to a hammer or a crane. They are not capable of functions we do not build in to them, and never will be. So whatever the future of technology is, we should not fear it.

Almost anyone will believe almost anything ... because they want to believe it's true, or because they are afraid it might be true.
- Terry Goodkind


*I have to say that I find many of his other conclusions highly questionable, although he does have some points that are worthy of consideration.

Sunday, 7 August 2011

Boom and Bust

Anyone unfortunate enough to stumble across my blog may be led to believe that I have no time or inclination for writing - after all, if I did there would be more posts, wouldn't there? The truth is rather different - I find it hard to choose what to write about, because it seems there are so many topics that urgently require my inspection. As a result I may make extensive notes about an idea and then never use it. It is a fact that I have fairly recently returned my appetite for knowledge so I must be a nett consumer of information if I am to get anywhere with anything. Hopefully I can return the fruits of my investigations to whoever is willing to read.

Lately I've been bending my will towards understanding economics. It seems that he field is muddy even to the experts, and assumptions and pitfalls abound. The 2008 crash showed that the banks didn't really know what they were doing, and before the crisis everyone thought the world was hunky-dory, so no-one else knew either, except a few like this guy. In fact I would hazard a guess that no one really knows what causes things like inflation, bubbles, deflation, crashes and the like. All we know is that generally if we put pressure on point x we get a response y. Thus when a country's official interest rate is lowered, inflation increases, and vice versa.

Most of today's economy seems to revolve around investors, in one way or another. The thinking is that no investor will willingly throw money away by buying into a bad deal, but the crash of 2008 showed this belief to be a fantasy. Governments can borrow money because investors are willing to give it to them - if they expect a return. Currencies are strengthen or weaken depending on how much faith investors have that the currency will stay strong or will weaken further. Companies can borrow money if banks think they will get a nett return, same for individuals. Investors bank money if they think the bank's practices are lucrative.

It does not take long to realise that this whole thing is a positive feedback loop. It all works if people are confident, but it rapidly goes down the toilet if people lose confidence. Granted this is a simplification but let's work with it for a moment. What are the checks? Where is the point where investment confidence is lost? Where is it gained? This article lists some of the causes and effects of four major crashes over the last century or so. They all have in common the formation of a "bubble" leading up to the crash. The first three have new rules associated with them that were intended to prevent future crashes. All of them failed. The Economists apparently ran out of talent, too, because no additional rules or institutions have resulted from the most recent crash, in order to prevent such a thing happening again. Instead we had costly bailouts, humiliatingly paid for by countries we might consider backward - China and the oil nations of the Middle East. In fact China is now the US's biggest creditor. The crashes we have suffered were either necessary, or they should direct us to restructure our finance. No one is claiming they were necessary and the Arab world laughed at us, saying their financial structures were more robust. So have we changed the way we do business? I should coco.

You may think I am having a downer on investors - after all, they are the link in the chain that has the most influence on the positive feedback - but I'm not, really. They are part of the problem but they are not the problem. The real problem is the way we do business. This article and the comments it sparked have some very interesting views, and suggest some solutions that are presently beyond me. It suggests that financial engineers are to blame for the crash, and to an extent they may be, but what is it about the system that makes financial engineering a tempting prospect in the first place? Why do bubbles form at all?

The answers to those questions are by no means obvious, and there is debate among economists on the answers. There are some things we can say with a reasonable degree of conviction, though. Firstly both the bubble and the crash are in principle based on investor psychology. It doesn't seem possible to identify one particular cause, instead a range of factors come into play.

A bubble is a type of inflation, except that in the real world if inflation causes a rise in the cost of, say, electricity, each kWh still has a genuine worth based on the production and distribution cost. Its worth is anchored in the work required to create it and get it into your house, or factory, or whatever. Of course demand can increase its price, but ultimately its worth can never go much above the economic benefit it gives to the buyer. Stocks, too, are subject to supply and demand. When a company is goes public its apparent worth is divided among stocks or shares, giving each of those shares a value that is defined by the total value of the company. The money raised from this partial sale is used to further the business. Over time the stocks of the company increase or decrease in value as investors buy or sell depending on whether they believe the company is growing or shrinking. Bad news, such as under-target profits, tend to depress the value of stock, and vice versa. But ultimately the real-terms value of stock is not known, it is only inferred from the company's past performance, market conditions and the company's current performance. So if investors suddenly believed that a company was going down the tubes they might sell all the public stock back to the company, resulting in a price drop that might make going down the tubes inevitable. A self-fulfilling prophecy. There is no anchor for the value of stocks, they are worth exactly what investors think they are worth. This becomes a problem when investors' beliefs are based on the beliefs of other investors. This was illustrated nicely when the dotcom bubble ocurred. Investors were so confident in the new business model that they thought such companies were worth more than their real value, resulting in a runaway investment boom that ended when everybody realised it was chaff. Some people legally made shed loads of cash by taking advantage of the investors' credulity. There is a word for such people. It is "conman". More can be found here. Similarly the bubble bursts when investors realise the bubble can no longer be sustained and opt out. A "correction" results, which, if the number of investors in the bubble is large enough, can become a crash, as investors with no exit strategy panic and sell as fast as possible to avoid heavy losses.

The model allows for rapid increases in stock prices, thus growing a company very fast, which can be a good thing, for sure, but this very volatility also gives rise to the possibility of a massive crash, resulting in a company losing value, likely ending up being undervalued. Instability is inherent in the system, so we either have to accept that crashes will occur and hope that the times of plenty make up for them, or we have to design a new system where stock valuations are not so volatile.

Sunday, 12 June 2011

Solving Zeno's Paradox

For those of you unfamiliar with Zeno of Elea, he was a Greek philosopher in the 5th century BC who proposed a series of paradoxes, mostly about motion, and how in the logic of the paradox it was impossible. I'm going to deal with just one of them, Achilles and the tortoise.

Imagine this scene: the Aegean sun is blazing on the white marble courtyards of Athens and Achilles has decided to race a toroise in it. Despite having rather fragile heels he is a sporting man and will thus allow the tortoise a significant head start on him. As the start of the race is signalled, by Socrates perhaps, asking the race organizer what a contest is, Achilles and the tortoise both set off, the tortoise with blazing fire and cracked cobblestones accompanying its supersonic progress ... oh wait, that's not right is it. Achilles runs, but half way to the tortoise's starting point he has a problem. He's traveled some distance but in that time the tortoise has moved away from him. He keeps on running despite this energy-sapping cogitation and ends up once again covering half the distance between where he was before and where the tortoise was before. Now he is starting to get confused. He's only a grunt after all, not a brain surgeon, and can't quite understand why the tortoise is still twice as far as Zenowill allow him to run. Before long his brain overheats and explodes, sending shrapnel into his heel and thus causing his demise, and the tortoise is declared the winner.

In the lucid prose of Aristotle: "In a race, the quickest runner can never overtake the slowest, since the pursuer must first reach the point whence the pursued started, so that the slower must always hold a lead."

So how are we to solve this paradox? You may have seen solutions involving calculus or algorithms courtesy of Cauchy or Leibniz or other brilliant mathematicians but these are solutions of the problem, not solutions of the paradox. They only show that the paradox can be resolved, not what is wrong with it in the first place.

To make my solution more obvious, I will reword the paradox slightly: "Achilles can never pass the tortoise because he must first travel half the distance between them, then half the remaining distance, and so on for ever."
Now to solve it. Firstly we must examine all the time terms in this statement. Zeno says that Achilles can never reach the tortoise, by which I take it to mean that no matter how much time he is given, he can not pass the tortoise. Secondly, assuming that Achilles's speed is constant, the time of each successive "step" is half that of the previous step. The paradox lies in assuming that it takes an infinite amount of time to do an infinite number of steps. The mathematical solutions will tell you this is not the case. If we only allow finite steps, as specified in the paradox, then yes, Achilles really can't cover the distance. After all, finite steps do not furnish him the required time to close the gap. And then even if we allow the number of steps to go to infinity, the infinite sum of xi = t/(2^i) is t, the time taken for Achilles to reach the tortoise but not to get past. To get past he actually needs more time than the paradox has allowed him. To draw level he needs exactly the time allowed him, but this is far from obvious and it took the genius of Archimedes to work it out.

So it is not really a paradox at all. First Zeno says he has all the time in the world, then he implicitly says that he only has less time than it takes to complete the task in the first place. This is a contradiction, not a paradox, but it's really hard to spot.

Tuesday, 31 May 2011

Forgive me if I get a little technical ...


As a bit of a technophile it's a fairly constant pleasure to see what can be done with consumer electronics these days. Advances apppear particularly dramatic in the field of computing, since most types of progress are exponential. This does have the side effect of making the whole thing seem a little pointless because if you buy your stuff this year then next year's processor will be twice as fast and use less power to boot. And that's not all, not by a long shot.

The expansion slots in your motherboard double in bandwidth every two years, seven months. The connectors feeding your hard drive double in bandwidth every two years, five months. External connections like USB and their ilk are a little more erratic but conservatively they double in bandwidth every two and a half years as well. I haven't done the sums but it'd be smart money to bet that RAM and CPU bandwidth are following a similar trend. If we project these trends to 2020 which, let's face it, is only nine years away, we can expect a colossal 2 Tbps over whatever graphics bus we're using then. Engineers are working to that goal now, you may depend on it. You can also expect a good 10 Gbps over the cable going to your external device, though, as today, whether you acheive the theoretical maximum may be a matter of "never". To put that into perspective, that's the kind of data rate the very latest graphics cards need to push those trillions of numbers around so the pretty lights happen on your screen in CoD.

It all seems rather excessive. And speaking of excess - yes, newer technology does take less power to do the same tasks as the silicon of yesteryear but don't forget that our ability to write code has ever been ahead of our ability to run that code. The best example to come from the game programmers is Crysis. When it was released in 2007 it had the singular distinction of being so catastrophically demanding at full setting that it was totally unplayable even if you had the best there was. My computer is three years younger than it and by any average person's standards it is a desktop supercomputer (the graphics cards can do about 4.1 TFLOPS), but wouldn't you know it I can't turn everything up to maximum either, not if I want to actually kill those Koreans. And as a result of all this, the total power consumption at maximum load is also going up quite a lot. I've just seen a 1.5 kW power supply. That could comfortably supply four PCs like mine at full chat, or in all likelyhood about seven of yours.

I do wonder, though, whether we will actually get to those kinds of speeds in consumer stuff. After decades of development we are reaching the point where the desktop computer can run photorealistic games at playable framerates. The trend is less towards more power from each chip as it is towards more chips. That's why the new AMD Phenom and the Intel i7 each have six processor cores. It's also why for some time now you could plug in two graphics cards, and now three or even four. And there's nothing stopping you from using those cards with two GPUs so in theory you could have eight GPUs in the one computer. If you are clinically insane.

Of course it is easy to imagine things that need ever more code and ever more processing as a result, but the returns are deminishing. In other words, there's not that much difference between "nearly photorealistic" and actually photorealistic, but there's a huge difference in terms of the processing required. If you don't believe me, consider that I can actually run Crysis quite nicely, but it took a 40,000 processor supercomputer some months to stitch together the complex physics and visuals of Avatar.

I guess the real question is whether gamers of the future will demand things like proper fluid dynamics and fully realistic destructible environments. Hardware tesselation is the showpiece of DX11 so perhaps the notoriously computationally intensive simulations like hair, fluids, cloth and refraction will be in the revisions to come. If they are, though, I really do hope we don't end up with something like an extremely furry wookie wearing Jedi clothes and swimming to Otoh Gunga. 'Cos if we do, we'll have gone backwards. Let's not fall into the trap of too eagerly computing things just because we can.

Friday, 6 May 2011

The Biblical basis for ... blogging?

In returning to blogging after a long absence (see the posts in 2008-10 as an example) I have sometimes considered a rather fundamental question: "why bother?" There are many successful blogs out there, no doubt influencing the thoughts of thousands of people each, but do I really believe that mine would reach that kind of influence? And if it did, what'd be the point anyway? Why do people need to know what I think at all?

Answering a question about a specific case is often difficult unless you have some concept of the bigger picture. A simple way of getting to the big picture is to generalise your own question first, then see if it becomes easier to answer. So if I ask, why do people need to know what I think at all? I can generalise by saying, why do people need to know what anyone thinks or has ever thought? In other words, what is the basis for pedagogy? In today's news there are few articles about the subject of education that don't implicitly or explicitly assume that education is important. I don't think anyone really stops to think of why this is, and why not? Is it so obvious that it doesn't require answering? In some ways it is - it is fairly clear that education has been a large influence in the advancement of Western society to the technological state we experience today. But then once you assert that it's good for building civilisation you have to ask, what is the basis for the desirability of civilisation?

As a Christian I try to take my guidance from what the Bible says about such things. It has plenty of words advising parents to teach their children God's Law, and about the history of God's people. Those things are important but they don't obviously illustrate the basis for general teaching of accumulated knowledge that is not directly about God, by which I mean all we have learned through science, logic, mathematics, philosophy and history. To find the basis for trying to understand nature and ourselves we need look no further than Genesis 1 where God said to the freshly minted mankind: "Fill the Earth and subdue it, and have dominion." To prepare us for the special duty of having dominion over the Earth and being faithful stewards of it, he provided us with curiosity about Himself. This curiosity spills over into curiosity about nature so that we ask the following two questions: how can we be better stewards of the people and land over which God has given us authority? what can we learn about God's nature from His creation?

Taken together, those questions ensure pedagogy, because as much as we have learned about how to do the first and what we have found out through the second, we have to teach our children and fellows so that whatever we have found that improves our ability to live in creation continues to influence future generations without them having to rediscover it, and whatever we have marvelled at in creation, if we pass on that knowledge our descendants can improve and expand on it.

To think that we have achieved all we see only in the last hundred years is a mistake. The 20th century was preceded by the 19th, and they weren't exactly living in caves. We think we are so advanced and enlightened, and we are, but we stand on the shoulders of thousands of generations of enquirers who, through their persistance, and by passing their knowledge on, have blessed every generation that has come after them. The cumulative effect of all this skill is the modern information age in which we live, and we are charged to be equally diligent in asking those two fundamental questions so that future generations can be blessed by us.

So that's the long answer as to why I should blog: I think of things other people might not, and if I don't pass them on, then what is the good of me ever having thought of them at all?

Friday, 29 April 2011

Farewell Oceanus, and we thank you.

I'm going to continue the previous post's theme of consumer products because I'd like to talk about Oceanus.

Consider this list: the Bugatti Veyron; Concorde; the SR-71; the Hubble Space Telescope; the Saturn V. Each a shining example of daring, engineering excellence, and a combination of money and a certain amount of fiscal irresponsibility. That is the reason why literally none of them are mass-market consumer goods. They peerless in every way.

Fortunately the Japanese have other ideas. They thought that more such peerless pieces of technology should grace the marketplace, at least this seems to have been the reasoning Casio took when they decided to launch Oceanus.

For those who don't know, Casio is an electronics company from Japan. Their presence in many countries is decidedly downmarket, but they have their eye on excellence as well. Many people will be familiar with their cheap digital watches, so favoured by schoolboys and terrorists, but what you might not know is that the cheap watches are only the tip of the iceberg. In Japan there is nothing downmarket about Casio and one could easily spend a thousand dollars or more on one of their watches. To try to market to this bracket abroad (particularly the US and Europe) they took a leaf out of Toyota's book and created a new prestige brand called Oceanus.

The brief was simple: all the functionality of the digital watch with the elegance of an analogue appearance, wrapped up in the best materials available and topped up with all the best features from Casio's extensive experience.

The result of this confluence of technology was the original oceanus: the first atomic solar chronograph watch. For practicality there was a small LCD screen to address the various changes in mode. It had solar power and a titanium case and bracelet - for me the #2 and #3 most important things in a watch (#1 is telling the time ... duh). It was also very good looking and despite the analogue appearance it still packed a high resolution stopwatch, some alarms, atomic time calibration, and world time.
Their next effort took things up a notch: they threw away the digital display entirely and replaced it with another hand to create the five motor.
Next they replaced the world time dial with one that showed the day of the week, a tide graph, and various other functions to create the 700 series, and to my eyes the best-looking Oceanus ever made. They also took some of the lessons learned from the Oceanus to their MT-G lineup, resulting in the 1000 series (my personal favourite).

Now it seems that the mid-level Oceanus are all but gone. Some of the high-end watches remain, but who can say if this is only because they are slower to sell? It seems like Concorde and some of the other technological showpieces I mentioned it is destined to rot in the back of a drawer after one of its motors fail or the battery finally wears out. And to me, this seems sad. In many ways we see to be going backward. We create something wonderful and because it's not made in Geneve, it's not quite good enough for us.

Monday, 21 March 2011

Time for a Tricorder

I believe it's time to start turning our mobile phones into the Tricorders they will eventually become. Here follows a rundown of the features I'd like to see on future handheld communications devices.

Modern mobile phones are pretty amazing devices. For an outlay of a thousand dollars or so you can get a large, efficient touch screen, a powerful CPU (and we are just starting to see the advent of mobile dual-core - clearly the industry is casting around for something to add in to make us all upgrade), accelerometers, GPS radio, GSM and HSDPA radio, bluetooth radio, FM receiver, magnetic digital compass, digital cameras and LED lights. This is undeniably an impressive list, and nearly all of it is thanks to the magic of semiconductors. However I believe that there are a number of items that could be added to this list in the near future, with a little innovation, that would turn the location, communication and calculation swiss army knife that is the modern phone into a true multi-talented mobile masterpiece.

1. Near IR night camera (with IR floodlight). Really, why haven't they done this already? It allows night time videography, so your friends' drunken antics will be even more clearly visible. Also good for spotting wildlife.

2. UV detector. Good for a day at the beach. Combined with the SPF rating of your sunscreen this could tell you how long you can stay in the sun before you start to burn.

3. Barometer. I have one of these in my watch so there's no reason you couldn't put it in a phone. You could use it to find your altitude indoors perhaps, or measure changes in altitude for a small amount of power (GPS uses a lot).

4. Electrical multi-meter. OK I know there are prefectly good multi-meters out there today but think of all the everyday items that have been absorbed by the mobile monster mash - clocks (have you noticed not many people wear watches these days?), calculators, Walkmans, handheld GPS and so on. Why not make the electrical fiddler proud of his new phone? You could even use the headphone socket for the probes.

5. Laser range-finder. Again this may not have mass-market appeal but maybe that's because no one has ever had access to such a thing before. People didn't know they needed accelerometers until those spirit level apps became available, after all, and now they use them all the time.

6. Laser temperature probe. Great for avoidance of a hot engine. Maybe you want to know if that saucepan has cooled down now.

7. Thermocouple. Again this could easily plug into the headphone or USB port, and allows you to find out how hot your coffee is, whether it's time to take out that cake, if your iced drink has cooled to 5 degrees yet, whatever.

8. Thermometer. This is a slightly dubious one since after your phone has been in your pocket all day it's only going to tell you how warm and snug a mouse would be were you to keep one in there. There are situations where it could be useful, though I suspect it would most commonly be used to complain to the building manager that the AC needs to be turned down.

9. Thermal camera. For me this is the holy grail. If a phone came out with a thermal camera I would sell my car for the privilege of owning one. This could help you find leaks in your house's insulation, look for computer components to cool, check out how well your cold weather clothing is working, the possibilities are endless. I'd use it for finding wildlife at night. Obviously with one of these the laser probe would be obsolete.

10. Light sensor. Yes, I know they already use those, but how about calibrating them and using them to tell us the luminous flux of light bulbs, the sun, whatever? That could be useful for photographers.

11. Geiger-counter. This is a bit of a niche application but I remember several occasions in physics lab at uni when I wanted for one of these. Also considering the amount of worry over radiation released by the nuclear industry these could help put people at their ease about fallout.

12. Solar cell. Unlike the others this isn't a sensor, but you could easily make part of the back of the phone into a solar cell that would help with battery life, possibly quite a lot. You could even arrange matters such that it charges the phone even if it is switched off, thereby giving you a full charge with no cables necessery.

Obviously no one is going to fit all of these to the one phone, but if manufacturers are really that desperate to sell, there are a few in that list that could be implemented today and would really set theirs apart from the others, perhaps even garnering them a reputation of catering for professionals. The resulting arms-race could be spectacular. And nearly all of these are present as semiconductor technologies today.

Now I know what you're thinking. You're thinking no one in their right mind would buy such a thing unless they needed all those features. Ever heard of a Swiss Army Knife? Yeah.